If you’re a professional wrestler, what’s the best way to humiliate your rival?
Is it smacking them repeatedly with a steel chair until they beg you to stop? Is it breaking a certain part of their body forcing them out of action for an indeterminate amount of time? What about cockblocking them so you can date their love interest and rub this new relationship in their face? Or how about forcing them to tap out to a particularly excruciating submission hold during a title match?
Nope.
The most surefire way to destroy your enemy’s self-esteem is to retire them. What’s more satisfying than that? Not only are you free to move on to the next program, you can take comfort in the fact that your vanquished rival will be seething powerlessly wondering where it all went wrong.
The retirement match, where one or both wrestlers put their careers on the line if they lose, is as old as the hills. It’s a gimmick best reserved for the most heated disputes that require permanent social distancing. What better place to showcase such a special encounter than at WrestleMania.
From the very first show 35 years ago to last year’s event, there have been special occasions where specific superstars were placed in career threatening situations only to have to work a little harder to get the duke. Otherwise, they’d have to join the audience while watching someone else take their spot.
Several years ago in this space, I noted five wrestlers who had their last match at Mania, whether they succumbed to an advertised stipulation or made a quiet off-camera decision. This was expanded to eight for a Huffington Post article in 2015. Kurt Angle is the most recent superstar to end his career, in this case willingly, at the Showcase Of The Immortals. He put over Baron…pardon me, King Corbin, on his way out the door in 2019.
Not mentioned in either of those pieces was the fact that Shawn Michaels is the only man in WWE history to retire twice at WrestleMania. 12 years before his final singles match with The Undertaker in 2010, a seriously injured Heartbreak Kid struggled through a back problem to give Stone Cold Steve Austin his first World title push at WrestleMania 14. It wasn’t a retirement match per se but because Michaels was in rough shape, he effectively ended his in-ring career immediately after. Thanks to a long, slow rehabilitation, he returned to full-time competition in the summer of 2002.
But not everyone put in the awkward position of having to defend their employment with the McMahon Family has had to say a premature good-bye to the job they love. Here are the three superstars who survived their retirement matches, including a certain son-in-law (twice, in his case), on the grandest stage of them all.
1. Andre The Giant (WrestleMania – March 31, 1985)
On the December 18, 1982 edition of Championship Wrestling, as noted by TheHistoryOfWWE.com, Big John Studd issued an open challenge on Buddy Rogers’ Corner. If you could somehow scoop him up and slam his giant ass to the mat, he would give you 500 smackers.
Curiously, fans from the audience were the first to try (or were they plants?). All would fail.
Then, it was up to the jobbers to have a go. Same result.
As the weeks went by, also recounted by The History Of WWE, the reward for bodyslaming Studd would continuously rise. During the Christmas 1982 episode of Championship Wrestling, it had doubled to a thousand. By early January 1983, it was raised to $3000. By the end of January, it was up to seven.
The future Mr. Perfect Curt Hennig made an attempt when it was $8000. No dice. SD Jones went for it when it was $8500. Nope. Tony Garea wasn’t able to do it when it was $9000 nor the much missed Gorilla Monsoon who tried when it got up to ten.
On the February 26, 1983 episode of Championship Wrestling, The History Of WWE website acknowledges Andre The Giant’s first encounter with his second most famous rival as he took his own shot. Thanks to the well timed interference of his manager “Classy” Freddie Blassie, Studd was spared from forking over the money. A couple of weeks later during a March 12 broadcast, the bodyslam challenge was suspended because, according to Blassie, as recounted by The History Of WWE, there were “no more worthy challengers”. Uh huh.
Andre and Studd had their first singles match two weeks later at the Boston Garden. The Giant won by count-out. Over the next two years, as The History Of WWE thoroughly documents, they would face off in countless more encounters at live events, only some of which were taped, and not always in one-on-one situations.
Early on, there were bodyslam teases where Andre would almost get the job done but either Studd would manage to wiggle free, hold onto the top rope or be saved by outside interference. According to TheHistoryOfWWE.com, during an September 18, 1983 episode of All-American Wrestling, it took all three future Conquistadors to stop Andre from winning the challenge.
In the build to the first WrestleMania in 1985, Studd, now represented by Bobby “The Brain” Heenan who took over for Blassie in the summer of 1984, issued his ultimatum. He would fight Andre in Madison Square Garden. It would not be a regular match. The Bodyslam Challenge, which had never really gone away despite no longer being a specific TV segment, would be the sole purpose of the bout. If Andre could get ‘er done, he’d earn $15000, the highest amount that would ever be offered. If he failed, he would have to retire. He’d have 60 minutes to make it happen.
It took him less than six. And when he got the money, Andre decided to throw it out to the fans until Heenan swooped in to take back the officially licensed WWF gym bag which held the remaining amount.
The result was probably not a surprise to those intimately familiar with the Andre/Studd rivalry. They already had a number of Bodyslam matches before back when the reward was $10000. (After losing one such encounter, it was Studd himself who stopped his rival from being generous with his reward.) Long before the first WrestleMania, Andre first slammed Studd, according to The History Of WWE, during an earlier MSG event on June 17, 1983 in one of the rare times he won by pinfall.
2. Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania 19 – March 30, 2003)
After the New World Order split in the aftermath of WrestleMania 18 and the end of his brief stint as Edge’s tag partner, The Racist One resumed being a solo act in the company that made him an icon. In the build-up to WrestleMania 19, Vince McMahon, in his thinly disguised Mr. McMahon heel persona, started being a pest to the former six-time World champion.
Having cost him a victory in a return match with The Rock at No Way Out in 2003, McMahon made it clear he hated Hogan. (He was ahead of his time.) He resented his departure for WCW a decade earlier and still held a grudge against him for testifying for the prosecution in the ultimately unsuccessful steroid trial that rocked the entire business.
McMahon went so far as to pull a Bobby Heenan. “Hulkamania is dead!” he unconvincingly declared. It has been replaced by McMahonmania. Sure.
All of this lead to a no holds barred street fight between the two at WrestleMania 19. McMahon challenged Hogan to put his career on the line as a key stipulation which he readily accepted.
During their inevitable on-screen contract signing on an episode of Smackdown!, the WWE chairman whacked Hogan in the head several times causing him to bleed. He then forced him to sign the deal with his own blood, as noted by Wikipedia.
During the match, Hogan was attacked by a mystery man with a lead pipe. That mystery man turned out to be “Rowdy” Roddy Piper in what would become his final, ill-fated heel run. It ultimately didn’t matter. Having already cashed in his receipt against his boss (he made him shed some blood in his own right), Hogan delivered a trio of leg drops to secure the victory and remain a WWE superstar.
3. Triple H (WrestleMania 29 – April 7, 2013 & WrestleMania 35 – April 7, 2019)
Stephanie McMahon’s husband is the only performer in the history of the event to have survived two retirement matches on the grandest stage of them all.
Back in 2012, when a returning Brock Lesnar started making unreasonable demands during an episode of Monday Night Raw, Triple H tried to reason with him hoping he would reconsider. Instead, he got attacked from behind setting up a trio of pay-per-view matches.
Lesnar won round one at SummerSlam 2012. As he did on Raw to kickstart the feud, Lesnar ultimately “broke” Triple H’s arm with a kimura lock. Just before the event, he made sure H’s old pal Shawn Michaels wouldn’t be in his corner so he F5’d him and broke his arm, too, assuring his absence.
Two months before round two at WrestleMania 29 nearly a year later, a now fully recovered Triple H, who didn’t make it to the bathroom before this Raw segment, went out to the ring to prevent The Beast from attacking his father-in-law for the second time. As he pissed his pants (there was no mistaking that big stain), The Cerebral Assassin slammed Lesnar’s head in the post causing him to accidentally bleed profusely (which, upon re-aired, repackaged replays looked even cooler in black and white).
Lesnar’s mouthpiece Paul Heyman insisted that H retire if The former Next Big Thing could beat him in their anything goes contest. With a fully recovered Michaels now ready to be in his corner, the tide turned. Triple H won with a pedigree on the bottom half of one of the steel steps inside the ring. (Lesnar would go on to win their final encounter inside a steel cage at Extreme Rules.)
Six years later, while Raw was celebrating Ric Flair’s 70th Birthday, a stunned Triple H watched his former Evolution brother Batista drag out The Nature Boy’s groggy carcass from his dressing room backstage. So began the build to another WrestleMania retirement angle.
Like Kurt Angle, Batista wanted one last pay-per-view match before signing off for good. (When you’re a big-time movie star, why continue to subject yourself to any more staged beatings for less money?) Triple H wasn’t interested in a fight, even though he had never pinned The Animal in their three previous high profile encounters. Batista pressured him to change his mind and also convinced him to put his own career at risk.
At WrestleMania 35, after clumsily tripping over his own feet as he first entered the ring, which led to a momentary break of character and a more cautious re-do, Batista went to war with The Game. Triple H was up for the fight. In a memorable spot, he pulled out the Blade Runner 2049 star’s nose piercing and later ran across a couple of announce tables to spear him through a third, stealing one of The Animal’s signature moves.
With a concerned Shawn Michaels on commentary and a returning Flair arriving in the final stages, H was handed his trusty sledgehammer from his still loyal Evolution compadre. Batista’s goal of having a clean sweep and finishing off The Game for good was lost. Triple H survived.
Dennis Earl
Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Tuesday, April 7, 2020
12:35 a.m.
Three Men Who Survived WrestleMania Retirement Matches
If you’re a professional wrestler, what’s the best way to humiliate your rival?
Is it smacking them repeatedly with a steel chair until they beg you to stop? Is it breaking a certain part of their body forcing them out of action for an indeterminate amount of time? What about cockblocking them so you can date their love interest and rub this new relationship in their face? Or how about forcing them to tap out to a particularly excruciating submission hold during a title match?
Nope.
The most surefire way to destroy your enemy’s self-esteem is to retire them. What’s more satisfying than that? Not only are you free to move on to the next program, you can take comfort in the fact that your vanquished rival will be seething powerlessly wondering where it all went wrong.
The retirement match, where one or both wrestlers put their careers on the line if they lose, is as old as the hills. It’s a gimmick best reserved for the most heated disputes that require permanent social distancing. What better place to showcase such a special encounter than at WrestleMania.
From the very first show 35 years ago to last year’s event, there have been special occasions where specific superstars were placed in career threatening situations only to have to work a little harder to get the duke. Otherwise, they’d have to join the audience while watching someone else take their spot.
Several years ago in this space, I noted five wrestlers who had their last match at Mania, whether they succumbed to an advertised stipulation or made a quiet off-camera decision. This was expanded to eight for a Huffington Post article in 2015. Kurt Angle is the most recent superstar to end his career, in this case willingly, at the Showcase Of The Immortals. He put over Baron…pardon me, King Corbin, on his way out the door in 2019.
Not mentioned in either of those pieces was the fact that Shawn Michaels is the only man in WWE history to retire twice at WrestleMania. 12 years before his final singles match with The Undertaker in 2010, a seriously injured Heartbreak Kid struggled through a back problem to give Stone Cold Steve Austin his first World title push at WrestleMania 14. It wasn’t a retirement match per se but because Michaels was in rough shape, he effectively ended his in-ring career immediately after. Thanks to a long, slow rehabilitation, he returned to full-time competition in the summer of 2002.
But not everyone put in the awkward position of having to defend their employment with the McMahon Family has had to say a premature good-bye to the job they love. Here are the three superstars who survived their retirement matches, including a certain son-in-law (twice, in his case), on the grandest stage of them all.
1. Andre The Giant (WrestleMania – March 31, 1985)
On the December 18, 1982 edition of Championship Wrestling, as noted by TheHistoryOfWWE.com, Big John Studd issued an open challenge on Buddy Rogers’ Corner. If you could somehow scoop him up and slam his giant ass to the mat, he would give you 500 smackers.
Curiously, fans from the audience were the first to try (or were they plants?). All would fail.
Then, it was up to the jobbers to have a go. Same result.
As the weeks went by, also recounted by The History Of WWE, the reward for bodyslaming Studd would continuously rise. During the Christmas 1982 episode of Championship Wrestling, it had doubled to a thousand. By early January 1983, it was raised to $3000. By the end of January, it was up to seven.
The future Mr. Perfect Curt Hennig made an attempt when it was $8000. No dice. SD Jones went for it when it was $8500. Nope. Tony Garea wasn’t able to do it when it was $9000 nor the much missed Gorilla Monsoon who tried when it got up to ten.
On the February 26, 1983 episode of Championship Wrestling, The History Of WWE website acknowledges Andre The Giant’s first encounter with his second most famous rival as he took his own shot. Thanks to the well timed interference of his manager “Classy” Freddie Blassie, Studd was spared from forking over the money. A couple of weeks later during a March 12 broadcast, the bodyslam challenge was suspended because, according to Blassie, as recounted by The History Of WWE, there were “no more worthy challengers”. Uh huh.
Andre and Studd had their first singles match two weeks later at the Boston Garden. The Giant won by count-out. Over the next two years, as The History Of WWE thoroughly documents, they would face off in countless more encounters at live events, only some of which were taped, and not always in one-on-one situations.
Early on, there were bodyslam teases where Andre would almost get the job done but either Studd would manage to wiggle free, hold onto the top rope or be saved by outside interference. According to TheHistoryOfWWE.com, during an September 18, 1983 episode of All-American Wrestling, it took all three future Conquistadors to stop Andre from winning the challenge.
In the build to the first WrestleMania in 1985, Studd, now represented by Bobby “The Brain” Heenan who took over for Blassie in the summer of 1984, issued his ultimatum. He would fight Andre in Madison Square Garden. It would not be a regular match. The Bodyslam Challenge, which had never really gone away despite no longer being a specific TV segment, would be the sole purpose of the bout. If Andre could get ‘er done, he’d earn $15000, the highest amount that would ever be offered. If he failed, he would have to retire. He’d have 60 minutes to make it happen.
It took him less than six. And when he got the money, Andre decided to throw it out to the fans until Heenan swooped in to take back the officially licensed WWF gym bag which held the remaining amount.
The result was probably not a surprise to those intimately familiar with the Andre/Studd rivalry. They already had a number of Bodyslam matches before back when the reward was $10000. (After losing one such encounter, it was Studd himself who stopped his rival from being generous with his reward.) Long before the first WrestleMania, Andre first slammed Studd, according to The History Of WWE, during an earlier MSG event on June 17, 1983 in one of the rare times he won by pinfall.
2. Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania 19 – March 30, 2003)
After the New World Order split in the aftermath of WrestleMania 18 and the end of his brief stint as Edge’s tag partner, The Racist One resumed being a solo act in the company that made him an icon. In the build-up to WrestleMania 19, Vince McMahon, in his thinly disguised Mr. McMahon heel persona, started being a pest to the former six-time World champion.
Having cost him a victory in a return match with The Rock at No Way Out in 2003, McMahon made it clear he hated Hogan. (He was ahead of his time.) He resented his departure for WCW a decade earlier and still held a grudge against him for testifying for the prosecution in the ultimately unsuccessful steroid trial that rocked the entire business.
McMahon went so far as to pull a Bobby Heenan. “Hulkamania is dead!” he unconvincingly declared. It has been replaced by McMahonmania. Sure.
All of this lead to a no holds barred street fight between the two at WrestleMania 19. McMahon challenged Hogan to put his career on the line as a key stipulation which he readily accepted.
During their inevitable on-screen contract signing on an episode of Smackdown!, the WWE chairman whacked Hogan in the head several times causing him to bleed. He then forced him to sign the deal with his own blood, as noted by Wikipedia.
During the match, Hogan was attacked by a mystery man with a lead pipe. That mystery man turned out to be “Rowdy” Roddy Piper in what would become his final, ill-fated heel run. It ultimately didn’t matter. Having already cashed in his receipt against his boss (he made him shed some blood in his own right), Hogan delivered a trio of leg drops to secure the victory and remain a WWE superstar.
3. Triple H (WrestleMania 29 – April 7, 2013 & WrestleMania 35 – April 7, 2019)
Stephanie McMahon’s husband is the only performer in the history of the event to have survived two retirement matches on the grandest stage of them all.
Back in 2012, when a returning Brock Lesnar started making unreasonable demands during an episode of Monday Night Raw, Triple H tried to reason with him hoping he would reconsider. Instead, he got attacked from behind setting up a trio of pay-per-view matches.
Lesnar won round one at SummerSlam 2012. As he did on Raw to kickstart the feud, Lesnar ultimately “broke” Triple H’s arm with a kimura lock. Just before the event, he made sure H’s old pal Shawn Michaels wouldn’t be in his corner so he F5’d him and broke his arm, too, assuring his absence.
Two months before round two at WrestleMania 29 nearly a year later, a now fully recovered Triple H, who didn’t make it to the bathroom before this Raw segment, went out to the ring to prevent The Beast from attacking his father-in-law for the second time. As he pissed his pants (there was no mistaking that big stain), The Cerebral Assassin slammed Lesnar’s head in the post causing him to accidentally bleed profusely (which, upon re-aired, repackaged replays looked even cooler in black and white).
Lesnar’s mouthpiece Paul Heyman insisted that H retire if The former Next Big Thing could beat him in their anything goes contest. With a fully recovered Michaels now ready to be in his corner, the tide turned. Triple H won with a pedigree on the bottom half of one of the steel steps inside the ring. (Lesnar would go on to win their final encounter inside a steel cage at Extreme Rules.)
Six years later, while Raw was celebrating Ric Flair’s 70th Birthday, a stunned Triple H watched his former Evolution brother Batista drag out The Nature Boy’s groggy carcass from his dressing room backstage. So began the build to another WrestleMania retirement angle.
Like Kurt Angle, Batista wanted one last pay-per-view match before signing off for good. (When you’re a big-time movie star, why continue to subject yourself to any more staged beatings for less money?) Triple H wasn’t interested in a fight, even though he had never pinned The Animal in their three previous high profile encounters. Batista pressured him to change his mind and also convinced him to put his own career at risk.
At WrestleMania 35, after clumsily tripping over his own feet as he first entered the ring, which led to a momentary break of character and a more cautious re-do, Batista went to war with The Game. Triple H was up for the fight. In a memorable spot, he pulled out the Blade Runner 2049 star’s nose piercing and later ran across a couple of announce tables to spear him through a third, stealing one of The Animal’s signature moves.
With a concerned Shawn Michaels on commentary and a returning Flair arriving in the final stages, H was handed his trusty sledgehammer from his still loyal Evolution compadre. Batista’s goal of having a clean sweep and finishing off The Game for good was lost. Triple H survived.
Dennis Earl
Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Tuesday, April 7, 2020
12:35 a.m.