Gene Siskel had a famous test for actors he observed in movies. If they looked good in close-up, they were stars. George C. Scott had his own set of criteria, three simple questions he asked himself every time he watched someone perform. 1. Is the actor well cast in the role they’re playing? 2. Do they make good emotional choices? And 3. Are they actually enjoying themselves?
Having seen you in Stay Alive and John Tucker Must Die, you easily pass Siskel’s test. And on the basis of watching you portray Brooke Davis on One Tree Hill and Ridley Lange on Nip/Tuck, you more than meet Scott’s criteria. The answer to all three of his questions is the same: an unreserved yes.
Unfortunately, despite thriving professionally, things are not so good for you personally. US Weekly broke the news this week that you’ve just split with Austin Nichols, a fellow actor few knew you were dating off-and-on until E! Online reported it two years ago. In fact, he took the job as Julian, the aspiring filmmaker who becomes romantically involved with Brooke on One Tree Hill, just to be closer to you.
Sophia Bush, I’m here for you. Forget about finding “the one”. That’s a bunch of old-fashioned bullshit that’s gotten you into trouble before. Forget about dating guys you work with. You know firsthand how awkward it can be to work with an ex. And forget about getting involved with guys in the business. They’re nothing but a waste of time.
What you need is someone who is your intellectual equal, not some empty-headed pretty boy who can’t keep up. You need someone you can spar with about politics and entertainment, not someone who doesn’t share your interests. And you need someone naturally monogamous, not a ho-bag.
Why not give this wire-thin Canadian mama’s boy a shot? What exactly have you got to lose? We’re close in age, we both love music and neither of us smoke or have siblings. True, I’m terrified of your pitbulls (I’ve never really been comfortable around dogs) and I’m no fashionista (one look through my dresser drawers and my closet would leave you deeply appalled) but I would be good company for you.
God knows we’d have plenty to talk about. I’d love to learn about your parents who I understand are both photographers. (By the way, which one is from Canada?) How long did it take them to fully accept that you were going to be an actor rather than a heart surgeon or a journalist? (You’ve said they were initially disappointed with your change of heart.) When you got the gig on OTH ten years ago, you were attending the University Of South Carolina and had to drop out. How many credits do you need to graduate and will you go back to finish them? (There’s no guarantee you’ll be a successful actor forever.)
What it was like attending Westridge School in Pasadena, a girls-only private educational institution? (Did you know that Julia Child studied there?) Why aren’t dudes allowed to go? Are we too distracting? Any regrets about not attending public school? How did you become the Rose Queen for the Tournament Of Roses parade in 2000? What was that experience like for you?
With regards to politics I have to warn you that we have very serious disagreements about President Obama. (I’ll never understand why you publicly supported the illegal assassination of Osama Bin Laden.) Although we both supported him in 2008 (you went so far as to become a volunteer helping him secure votes by touring college campuses on his behalf), I’m appalled by his piss-poor record on civil liberties, his paranoid bullying of conscientious whistleblowers (including the still wrongly incarcerated Bradley Manning), his inconsistency on gay issues, his lack of respect for the Muslim world, his disturbing support for Endless War and the Surveillance State, and his disappointing allegiance with the 1%. Last month, you mentioned in an interview how you’ve been disappointed, too, but you really let him off the hook. Based on what I’ve seen and read, Obama was never serious about being a liberal game changer. I could argue with you about this all day long.
I’d love to know more about all your humanitarian pursuits, particularly the environmental causes you’ve been championing in recent years. I don’t know how you find the time to do it considering your work schedule but I greatly admire your passion to accomplish actual positive change rather than just repeat catchy, empty slogans like a certain President I could mention who lacks your commitment and convictions.
As much as I’ve enjoyed your work on OTH and the first season of Nip/Tuck, you need to pick better movies. I mentioned Stay Alive and John Tucker Must Die earlier. The former was terribly unscary and the latter was terribly unfunny. You’ve proven on Television that you can be humourous, sexy, snotty, vulnerable, heroic and lovable in the same role. I’m concerned you’ll never find another part as compelling and challenging as Brooke Davis. I’m hoping you prove me wrong. (Maybe I’ll find a hidden gem in your filmography. I haven’t seen everything.) I hate to see someone as talented as you flounder in films that are beneath you. You deserve better.
On the plus side, I’m glad you got cast in Partners, a new comedy pilot created by the people that brought us Will & Grace. I hope it’s funny enough to get picked up as a series. Best of luck to you. As you know full well, simultaneous artistic and commercial successes are often elusive in this business. Maybe lightning will strike twice for you on TV.
Whatever you decide to do about your career and love life, I wish you well. And with that, I offer you this:
I’m a sucker for a pinkish hue
Sophia Bush, I’m here for you
Dennis Earl
Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Saturday, February 18, 2012
1:41 a.m.
Katie Holmes, I’m Here For You
People Magazine just broke the story yesterday. You’ve dumped your husband after only six years of marriage. It was your first go-around with legal matrimony, his third. According to TMZ, you’re very concerned about your adorable young daughter’s possible indoctrination into Scientology, your husband’s “religion”, hence your decision to file for sole custody of 6-year-old Suri. Considering all the horror stories in the media about L. Ron Hubbard’s phony philosophy, I don’t blame you at all. In fact, I’m wondering why you didn’t come to this conclusion sooner.
You’re doing the right thing getting as far away from that maniacal couch-jumper as humanly possible. He’s out of his mind. (Have you heard him laugh? Even the Joker thinks he’s nuts.) Honestly, you can do so much better than Mr. Mapother IV.
Katie Holmes, I’m here for you. Sure, I’m built like a rake and dance like a spaz, but I’m also an atheist who could care less about religions both nutty and mainstream. (I prefer thinking for myself.) Besides, considering how contentious your divorce proceedings are likely to be, maybe a fun fling with a silly Canadian is exactly what you need right now.
We’d certainly have lots to talk about. First off, I’d love to know about all your film experiences. I was particularly impressed with your small role in Wonder Boys, one of the best films of the last decade. You played a college student named Hannah who’s got it bad for her deeply troubled professor Michael Douglas. He’s having an affair with the married Frances McDormand, he accidentally killed her dog, he’s trying to nurture the writing talent of the offbeat Tobey Maguire and he’s struggling with the manuscript for his second novel (it’s well over 2000 pages long and late for delivery to the publisher).
In a key scene late in the picture, after begging Douglas over and over again to allow you the chance to read his work in progress, you offer him a memorable line of criticism that completely changes his life: “You didn’t make any choices.”. It’s so perfectly simple and correct that only a completely stressed and distracted middle-aged professional deeply afraid of all his own personal turmoil would not think of it himself.
I also enjoyed your supporting performance in Batman Begins, one of the best comic book movies I’ve ever seen. I never understood the criticism you received for playing Rachel Dawes, Bruce Wayne’s love interest in the film. You held your own with the always intense Christian Bale. Why didn’t you return for The Dark Knight?
I’ve also admired your appearances in The Ice Storm (the entertaining Ang Lee drama that marked your film debut), the gripping Phone Booth, and even that fun cameo with your Dawson’s Creek co-star and ex-boyfriend, Joshua Jackson, in the otherwise uneven Muppets From Space. It’s cool that you have a good sense of humour.
What did you think of Abandon? I felt the ending completely undermined the entire film. It turned a so-so thriller into a ridiculous one. Sadly, it’s your worst feature but I blame Oscar winner Stephen Gaghan’s preposterous script more than anything else. It marked a steep decline from the writing he did for Traffic, a much stronger project.
I love the story of how you got the part of Joey on Dawson’s Creek, the TV show that made you a star 15 years ago. Because you were previously committed to performing in your high school production of Damn Yankees (you played Lola) and didn’t want to let anyone down by dropping out, you had to decline an invitation to audition for creator Kevin Williamson in person. So, they allowed you the chance to submit a video audition instead. Was it all done in one take?
Speaking of TV, what did the Kennedy family think of your portrayal of Jackie O in The Kennedys miniseries? What preparation did you undertake to play a Slutty Pumpkin on How I Met Your Mother? And what were you going to do for three episodes of Friends?
You’ve mentioned that you’re a painter. How often do you get the chance to do that? What do you like to paint and how would you describe your approach? Any other non-acting creative ventures you like to pursue?
I’m sorry things didn’t work out for you in your marriage and hope that your divorce will be swift and amicable. Whatever you decide to do with your love life and career, I wish you well. And with that, I offer you this:
When you’re looking for shelter from the public zoo
Katie Holmes, I’m here for you.
Dennis Earl
Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Saturday, June 30, 2012
4:29 p.m.